Use this to search the site! Just type your request in the blank and click!
Re: Cheesy Sandwich
On 10/19/2026 3:12 PM, Lisa wrote:
Dear Uncle Phaedrus,
I hope you can help because I have been haunted by a particular sandwich I made once in my 1979 7th grade home economics class. I have searched high and low and have found something slightly similar called Cheese Delights, but it’s really not the same. I wonder if you could help?
Slice of white bread
The great gobs (to my mind) of Miracle Whip were stirred in with the cheese to form a somewhat loose but very cohesive mixture (similar to the mayo and cheese mix that was spooned onto canned pear halves for pear salad) which was mounded high atop the bread with tomato slice. It stood at the center about two inches or so above the surface of the bread and was spread to connect with the bread’s crust like a meringue is spread over a pie. Season with salt and pepper and broil until the surface begins to brown in spots.
As a kid for whom tomato slices on sandwiches still spelled a wet bread disaster and for whom copious amounts of Miracle Whip induced shudders, I had little regard for this simple sandwich. But then I tasted it.
Thank you for your time,
Subject: Re: Cheesy Sandwich
From: Phaedrus
Date: 10/20/2026, 5:45 AM
To: Lisa
I don’t recall the name and when I first read the recipe we were about to prepare, though not a picky eater, I was disappointed. This was to be a broiled, open faced sandwich and broiling was a new technique but the ingredients did not appeal:
Slice of tomato
Chopped or grated American cheese (or possibly cheddar?)
Generous portion of Miracle Whip
Salt and pepper
I didn’t anticipate how the Miracle Whip would brown and the heat would transform the ingredients into a delicious surprise. The pyramid of cheese salad leveled off a bit but was still a pretty thick, distinctive layer. It hid completely the tomato slice and didn’t fully melt down once heated-unlike the other recipes I have found with similar ingredients. I have looked off and on for years in vintage and regional recipe books. It’s got to be somewhere but I haven’t found it. I would love to have an accurate recipe so I can try it again.
I went to Carmody Jr High School in the Denver area but, again, that was in 1979.
Lisa
I did not have any success looking for an open-faced sandwich that fits your description exactly and gives in so many words a connection with Carmody Jr High School in Denver. However, my associate Gemini tells me the below.
Phaed
Gemini:
That dish sounds like a variation of the classic **Broiled Tomato and Cheese Puff** (or **Broiled Cheese & Tomato Toastie**), which was a standard staple of middle school and high school Home Economics (Home Ec) curricula across the United States throughout the 1970s and 1980s!
Because Home Ec classes in that era focused heavily on teaching basic cooking techniques (like using an oven broiler, knife skills, and measuring), simple dishes with everyday pantry staples—such as Miracle Whip, pre-sliced white bread, tomato, and grated cheese—were hugely popular. Mixing grated/shredded cheese into Miracle Whip creates a spreadable, soufflé-like "cheese puff" topping that expands, browns, and bubbles beautifully when broiled without separating or burning immediately.
Here is the reconstructed recipe so your client can recreate that exact Home Ec memory at home:
**1970s Home Ec Broiled Tomato & Cheese Puff**
**Ingredients (Per Sandwich)**
* **1 slice** White sandwich bread (lightly toasted on a baking sheet first so it doesn't get soggy underneath)
**Instructions**
1. **Preheat the Broiler:** Set your oven broiler to **HIGH** and position the top rack about 4 to 6 inches away from the heating element.
5. **Broil:** Place the baking sheet back under the broiler for **2 to 4 minutes**. Watch it closely—it is done as soon as the cheese mixture puffs up, melts together, and forms appetizing golden-brown spots on top.
6. **Cool & Serve:** Let it cool for 1–2 minutes before serving (the tomato slice retains heat!).
Why This Combination Worked So Well in Home Ec:**
* **The Miracle Whip Secret:** Miracle Whip contains emulsified eggs, oil, vinegar, and sugar. When mixed with grated cheese and subjected to direct broiler heat, the emulsion creates a light, bubbly crust (similar to a mayonnaise-based dip or a soufflé puff) rather than just melting flat like a standard slice of cheese.
* **1–2 slices** Fresh ripe tomato (thickly cut)
* **1/2 cup** Shredded or finely chopped American cheese (or sharp yellow cheddar)
* **2 to 3 tablespoons** Miracle Whip (the tangy flavor is key to matching that original recipe)
* **Dash** of salt and freshly cracked black pepper
2. **Toast the Bread:** Place the slice of white bread on a baking sheet and broil it for 1–2 minutes, just until lightly toasted on both sides. *(Home Ec teachers always emphasized pre-toasting to handle the juice from the tomato!)*
3. **Mix the Topping:** In a small bowl, stir together the shredded cheese, Miracle Whip, salt, and pepper until it forms a thick, cohesive cheese paste.
4. **Assemble:**
* Lay the tomato slice(s) directly on top of the toasted bread.
* Spoon the cheese/Miracle Whip mixture over the tomato, spreading it all the way to the edges of the bread to seal the tomato completely underneath.
* **The Tang:** The signature zip of Miracle Whip cuts through the rich cheese and pairs perfectly with the acid of the tomato.