Sent: Thursday, February 19, 2015 11:45 PM
Subject: magic pan recipes
I can't believe my luck I running across your website! Our family has been
mourning the loss of one our favorites from the old Magic Pan.....the deep
fried ham crepes with the mustard sauce....and there the recipe was on your
site. Thank you soooooooo much! I'm going to make them for an Oscars party
Now there is another one that would be great to have. Porkys Drive inn in
Minneapolis, Minnesota used to serve a deep fried onion ring that was second
to none. There was a thick batter. Any chance this might be out there? The
Traulson family sold the drive inn a couple of years ago, but they operate a
full service restaurant called Triggs in Minneapolis. Any help would be
There's a photo of Porky's onion rings here: Porky's Onion Rings
There is an article about the closing of Porky's here: Twin Cities
In that article, Tryg Truelson, son of the owner of Porky's, was asked if
he'd reveal the secret onion ring recipe.
"'Not a chance', he said. He's using it to make onion rings in his other
restaurant, Tryg's, in Minneapolis."
He does offer "Porky's onion rings" on the menu at his restaurant in
Minneapolis, which is called "Tryg's".
However, there's some question about what is actually "secret" about the
recipe. In the book, "Minnesota Eats out: An Illustrated History" by Kathryn
Strand Koutsky and Linda Koutsky(available at Amazon.com), the authors
reveal a recipe for Porky's onion rings. From the statements accompanying
the recipe, they appear to be saying that the recipe in their book is the
original Porky's onion rings recipe from the 1950s, and if you use Lawry's
seasoned salt in the batter, then you will have the original recipe. It
appears that the Traulsons later developed their own seasoning salt recipe
and began using that instead, and the seasoning salt recipe is the secret
recipe, not the onion rings recipe. The recipe is below. Use Lawry's
seasoned salt where it calls for seasoning salt;go easy on the regular salt,
if you use any. Remember, these will taste like the Porky's onion rings from
the 1950s, not the later ones, which use the secret seasoning salt. The
secret seasoning salt remains a secret, but if you go to Tryg's Restaurant
in Minneapolis, you can get Porky's onion rings there.
"Minnesota Eats out: An Illustrated History" by Kathryn Strand Koutsky and Linda Koutsky
Porky's Onion Rings
1 extra large egg
2 cups whole milk (important to use whole milk)
2 tablespoons (or less, to taste) seasoning salt (use Lawry's - Phaed)
4 cups plus 1 tablespoon Gold Medal flour
Extra Large yellow onions
(Note: the original recipe also calls for regular salt, about 5 teaspoons
for a recipe of these proportions;use if you like a lot of salt.)
Combine the first 4 ingredients and beat with a wire whip for several
minutes, until very smooth. Refrigerate for at least 1 hour.
Slice extra-large yellow onions into rounds; break apart into individual
rings. Dip rings into batter using a long-handled fork. Drop
rings into hot oil, at least 360 degrees. Cook rings until medium golden
brown. If desired, sprinkle with more seasoning salt before
serving. Serves 6 to 8.
You are truly amazing...what a very thorough approach. Thank you again for solving these recipe mysteries!
Sent: Thursday, October 05, 2017 4:58 PM
Subject: Porky's Onion Ring Receipe
The other day I found your receipe for Porkys onion rings and I couldn't
wait to make them. I followed the receipe to the letter and all I got was a
huge ball of flour paste. What a disappointment. the receipe said 2 cups
milk, 4 cups flour. That equals paste. I attached a picture of the glob. I
grew up eating these delicious rings and would love a receipe that works.
I'm sorry the Porky's onion rings recipe didn't work for you. I 'm not a
cook myself; I just search for recipes that people ask for. I could not
possibly try them all before posting them. You can see from that post on my
site at 3-23-2015,
that the recipe came from a book (page 142) called "Minnesota Eats Out" by
Kathryn Strand Koutsky and Linda Koutsky with recipes by Eleanor Ostman.
I went back and checked the posted recipe against the book, and they are
exactly the same, so if there is a mistake in the recipe, the mistake is
in the book. I do occasionally make typos, but apparently not in this case.
The recipe has been posted for 2 1/2 years now, and I have never gotten a
complaint about the recipe until yours. That same recipe is posted on other
sites around the web, and I saw only one comment: someone said the onion
rings did taste like Porky's, but that it was difficult to get the consistency
right. 4 cups plus one tablespoon of flour to 2 cups milk plus 1 egg does
seem a little out of proportion. Did you try adding more milk a little
at a time to your glob and thoroughly whipping it until the consistency
seemed right? That's my best suggestion. Recipes are not always perfect,
and there are sometimes misprints even in printed books. Sometimes you
have to do some tweaking.
There does not appear to be another recipe available anywhere for Porky's
Postings of the same recipe on other sites:
Try either of these suggestions:
1. Start with 2 cups of milk, egg, and salt. Slowly whip in flour until the
batter consistency is suitable. Be sure to whip this batter thoroughly.
2. Start with 4 cups of flour plus 1 tablespoon. Add the egg and salt, then
whip in milk gradually until the batter consistency is suitable. Be sure to
whip this batter thoroughly.
You might even try using an electric mixer on low instead of the whip.
I'll post this beneath the posting on my site as a caution to others who
might try the recipe.
Sent: Thursday, February 19, 2015 10:33 AM
Hi, hoping you can help.
When a Chili's Restaurant opened in our area I fell in love with a soup they served then. After they took it off the menu,
I finally figured out how to clone it; recipe below. As you can see there, I found what worked for a "secret ingredient".
But then that product has been taken off the market. So what I hope you can find is either the original recipe from Chili's,
or another product to substitute for the missing chicken product. Clear as mud? It was on the original menu quite a long time,
but now that's about 10 years ago.
I can send a description of the canned chicken item if that helps or is needed. Am pretty sure it was a Swanson product;
did email them but they said they were no longer making it. Thanks. Marilyn
Chili Chicken Mushroom Soup
4 c. chicken broth, divided
2 tsp. chicken bullion granules, divided
1/2 c. minced yellow onion
8 - 10 oz. sliced fresh mushrooms
5 T. butter or margarine
1/3 c. flour
1 c. light cream
1 4.5 oz. can Mixin' Chicken & it's liquid (don't substitute, this was the secret ingredient !)
Salt & white pepper
1 4.5 oz. can chopped green chilies, divided
Shredded sharp cheddar*
Pico de Gallo:* minced onion, diced tomato, slivered fresh jalapeno, snipped parsley & cilantro
In a medium skillet, simmer onion & mushrooms in half of broth with half of bullion till tender, about 25
minutes, halving most of the 'shroom slices as you cook. Meantime, mix enough pico de gallo to top
the number of servings you'll need, & chill it.
In a 4 qt. soup pot, melt butter on Medium heat, blend in flour slowly & smoothly. Slowly add rest of
broth, bouillon, cream, & the onions & mushrooms with their liquid. Cook, stirring, on Medium heat
till soup thickens and tries to boil, 15 to 22 minutes. Take off heat. Stir in chicken and all but 2 tsp. of
the diced chilies; season to taste; should not be too highly seasoned. Toss the reserved chilies with
the pico de gallo. Serve the soup topped with cheese plus the pico de gallo, with crackers on the side.
Makes 4 - 6 bowls, about 8 cups.
This can be frozen, but add more chilies when you re-heat it, as they lose some of their flavor.
And an *alternate topping that's good too: Sour cream, topped with chopped nacho slices & sliced ripe olives.
You were using Swanson’s canned chicken (Mixin’ Chicken) in your soup, and that product has been discontinued.
Chili’s probably used a pre-cooked, prepackaged chicken & broth in their original recipe, but I have no idea
of a brand name. It might be a commercial brand that’s only available via Food Service companies. There are
several things you can try, and I’ll list them:
1) Try the copycat recipe for Chili's Chicken Mushroom Soup that’s posted in dozens of places on the Internet.
It uses chicken + chicken broth. It’s claimed to have been developed by a former Chili’s employee and is said
to be very good. See the recipe below.
2) Find another brand of canned chicken and use that. The biggest problem here is that Swanson’s Mixin’ Chicken
was canned in broth, and all of the other brands of canned chicken that I can find are canned in water. Chicken
canned in water is probably not going to have enough flavor by itself. If you can’t find another brand that’s
canned in broth (I didn't find one.), then you’ll have to add extra chicken broth separately to build up the
flavor. The other brands of canned chicken that I saw were: “Brookdale”, Walmart’s “Great Value”, Tyson, Bumblebee,
Kirkland, Sweet Sue, Hormel, Valley Fresh, and Trader Joe’s. One site rated “Brookdale” and “Great Value” highly
and “Trader Joe’s” as not being as satisfactory.
3) Unable to find a product that is canned, precooked chicken & broth, you’re going to have to add the chicken
meat and extra chicken broth separately. For a really tasty soup, you could get a rotisserie chicken at your
supermarket and pick off the meat, using it with canned broth. Of course, you could also cook your own chicken
and make your own broth. If these are too much, then my best suggestion is #2. You may have to try several brands
of canned chicken and broth before you get a taste that’s close to what you had with the Swanson’s. You might
combine elements of your own recipe and the one below to reach an acceptable compromise recipe. The below recipe
makes a much larger quantity of soup.
Former Chili's employee’s copycat: Chili's Chicken and Mushroom Soup Copycat
Chili's Chicken and Mushroom Soup Copycat
1/2 stick margarine
1/4 cup celery, diced
1/4 cup carrots, diced
1/4 cup yellow onions, diced
3 cups mushrooms, sliced
1/2 cup flour
5 1/2 cups chicken broth
pinch of dried tarragon
1/4 teaspoon thyme
1 teaspoon black pepper
1/2 teaspoon hot pepper sauce
1 teaspoon fresh parsley, chopped
3 cups half and half
1 1/2 teaspoons lemon juice
3/4 pound chicken, cooked and diced
Melt the butter on a large soup pot.
Add the vegetables and sauté until tender over medium heat.
Add the flour and stir constantly.
Slowly add the chicken broth.
Add herbs, pepper sauce and parsley to the pot and stir well. Simmer for 10 minutes.
Stir in the half and half, lemon juice and chicken. Bring to a simmer and cook 10 minutes.
Sent: Thursday, February 19, 2015 2:23 PM
Subject: Re: Chili's Chicken Mushroom Soup
Phaed....thanks for your speedy reply.........wish my son was as on the ball as you are !
I'll try the clone you sent, but, honestly, can't think it's the same as the version our local restaurant
served because there are no chilies in it & no topping, & those 2 things were major to the yummyness of
the local product.
I've been wondering if using Swanson's Flavor Boost product & canned chicken meat might be an answer;
I don't really know what Flavor Boost is, a strong bouillon granule???? a condensed broth???? & I hate
to buy it not knowing if I'll ever use the rest of the box. I know I SHOULD try to do it with home or
deli cooked chicken, more healthy no doubt.
Anyway you've given me some ideas & something to try, so thanks very much, once again. Marilyn
According to Swanson, their “Flavor Boost - chicken” is a concentrated chicken broth. It might be worth trying.
Let me know how it turns out if you do try it.
Sent: Friday, February 20, 2015 11:27 AM
Subject: Re: Chili's Chicken Mushroom Soup
Phaed, thanks so much. How did you determine that? No matter, I'm sure I can make use of leftovers in that case.
Will let you know results. Still colder than we like it in north central Florida, so still "soup weather".
Thanks again. Marilyn
Sent: Friday, February 20, 2015 3:45 PM
Subject: WW II era frosting recipe
Hi, I'm looking for a frosting recipe for my 80 year old father. It was his favorite in childhood.
It is called "Melody Meringue", "Mellow Meringue", or "Mallow Meringue". He was born in 1935 so it
would probably be a WW II era recipe. He remembers it as a cooked frosting, not too sweet and very
creamy. I suspect it is a variant of the roux based "Gravy Frosting" or "Boiled Frosting ", common
in that era. I have had no luck with Google or any of my old cookbooks. Thank you in advance for any
help you can offer.
Well, duplicating your efforts, I had no success finding any frosting recipe called "Melody Meringue",
"Mellow Meringue", or "Mallow Meringue". I checked several cookbooks from before 1950 as well, with no
success. What I get from the recipes that I did find is that “meringue frostings” and a type of frosting
called “marshmallow frosting” are pretty much the same thing. They are both fluffy white frostings
usually made with egg whites. There may have been one of these called “marshmallow meringue frosting”,
and perhaps that’s what your father recalls.
There’s a recipe and a photo of a marshmallow frosting here. If you show it to him, maybe it will look
familiar to him: Cake Duchess
There are also a couple of recipes below. The first one is a meringue frosting that does not have the egg whites.
The second is a typical marshmallow or meringue cooked frosting.
1 c. white or brown sugar
1/4 tsp. cream of tartar
1/8 tsp. salt
1/3 c. water
1 tbsp. light corn syrup
Bring to a boil and add to 1 unbeaten egg whites and 1 teaspoon vanilla. Beat until stiff.
This makes about 2 cups frosting and will not crust over.
8 large egg whites, at room temperature
2 cups granulated sugar
1/2 teaspoon cream of tartar
1/8 teaspoon fine salt
2 teaspoons vanilla extract
1 Fill a medium saucepan with 1 inch of water and bring it to a simmer over medium heat.
2 Place the egg whites, sugar, cream of tartar, and salt in the clean bowl of a stand mixer and
whisk by hand to combine. Nest the bowl over the saucepan, making sure the bottom of the bowl is
not touching the water. Heat the egg white mixture, whisking constantly, until the sugar has
dissolved and the mixture is hot to the touch (about 120°F on an instant-read thermometer),
about 6 minutes.
3 Transfer the bowl to a stand mixer fitted with the whisk attachment. Turn the mixer to medium
and whisk for 1 minute. Increase the speed to high and whisk until stiff, glossy peaks form, about
5 minutes more. Add the vanilla and whisk until just incorporated, about 1 minute. Use immediately
or store in an airtight container at room temperature for up to 3 hours.
Gwen sent these:
1/2 pound marshmallows
1 tablespoon milk
2 egg whites
1/4 cup sugar
1/4 teaspoon salt
1/2 teaspoon vanilla
Heat marshmallows and milk together, folding over until marshmallows are half melted. Remove from heat
and continue folding until mixture is smooth and fluffy. Beat egg whites, add sugar gradually and
continue beating until stiff and smooth. Add salt and vanilla. Blend into marshmallow mixture.
Marshmallow Meringue Icing
2 egg whites, beaten
1 cup granulated sugar
1/4 cup chopped nut meats
8 marshmallows, cut in quarters.
Beat egg whites until they Just begin to hold their shape in peaks. Then gradually add the granulated sugar,
beating constantly while adding the sugar. Fold in the nut meats and the marshmallows, cut in quarters.
Marshmallow Meringue Icing
3 egg whites
one cup marshmallow cream
1 tsp vanilla
dash of salt
Beat 3 egg whites with a dash of salt until stiff. Beat in one cup marshmallow cream, a heaping tablespoonfull
at a time, continuing to beat until mixture forms peaks that curve over slightly. Fold in one teaspoon vanilla.
Angel Mallow Icing
1/2 c. sugar
2 egg whites, room temperature
2 c. marshmallow cream
1/2 tsp. vanilla
2 tbsp. water
A hand beater works best for this recipe. Combine sugar, egg whites and water in top of double boiler,
and beat over boiling water until soft peaks form. Add marshmallow cream beat until stiff peaks form.
Remove from heat add vanilla.
1 cup granulated sugar
1/3 cup water
1/4 teaspoon cream of tartar
2 egg whites
1 teaspoon vanilla
8 regular marshmallows
Place water, sugar, and cream of tartar in a small saucepan with candy thermometer. Turn heat on medium and
bring ingredients to soft ball stage. Beat egg whites until stiff. When syrup reaches soft ball stage,
drop in quartered marshmallows. Immediately turn on mixer and pour the sugar and marshmallows slowly into
egg whites. Marshmallows will melt in bowl during the beating. Add vanilla and beat until icing holds its shape.
1 3/4 c. sugar
3/8 c. water
2 egg whites, room temperature
1/4 tsp. salt
1/2 tsp. cream of tartar
1/4 lb. marshmallows
1/2 tsp. vanilla
3 or 4 drops food coloring if desired
Place sugar, water, unbeaten egg whites, salt and cream of tartar in top of double boiler over boiling water.
Beat until soft peaks form, using an electric beater if possible. Remove from heat and stir in marshmallows.
Beat until marshmallows are dissolved, then add vanilla and beat until of spreading consistency.
Marshmallow Meringue Filling
1 3/4 cups sugar
? teaspoon salt (1/4 tsp is a good guess)
1/2 cup water
1/2 cup marshmallows
Whites of 3 eggs, whipped
1/2 teaspoon baking powder
Mix sugar, salt and water, add marshmallows and boil without stirring until syrup spins a thread.
Add slowly to beaten egg whites. Add baking powder and beat until firm enough to spread